Menu | The Bagel Exchange

Dozen Bagels
Flavors: Blueberry, Cinnamon Raisin, French Toast, Plain, Poppy Seed, Pumpernickel, Cheddar Cheese, Multi-Grain, Sesame, Onion, Jalapeño Cheddar, Garlic, Sundried Tomato, & Everything
$13.99
Bagel only
$1.35
Bagel
With butter or Jelly$2.50
With plain cream cheese$3.00
With flavored cream cheese (Maple Walnut, Chocolate Chip, Apple Cinnamon Raisin, Strawberry, Vegetable, Scallion, low fat or the monthly special.)$3.25
Muffins (Blueberry, Cappuccino Chocolate Chunk, Strawberry Rhubarb or Blueberry Lemon) or a Cinnamon Bun
$2.25
Scones (Apple Cinnamon, Blueberry or Raspberry White Chocolate)
1$1.25
3 for $3$3.00

Order lunch #1-#13 or design your own Custom Bagel Sandwich

(Design your own: DYO) $8.49

served hot, or cold. Alternate bread choices: Kaiser Roll, Croissant, or Wraps.

Choose Bagel Flavor
Decide on Deli Meats & Cheeses:
Meats: Tavern Ham, Roast beef*, Smoked Turkey, Pastrami*, Buffalo Chicken, Pepperoni*, Salami, Chicken.
Cheeses: American, Provolone, Swiss, or shredded Cheddar (*additional charge applies for these)
Decide on Toasting options
Add toppings; lettuce, tomato, red onion, and choice of dressing.

#1 NY’s Finest
Smoked Salmon, plain cream cheese, capers and red onions, served on an everything bagel.
$9.29
#2 NYPD Blue
Thin Sliced Chicken with ham and melted Swiss cheese topped w/lettuce, tomato, Mayo & served on a Multi-Grain Bagel.
$8.49
#3 The Chief
A Reuben with Hot Pastrami, melted Swiss cheese, sauerkraut & thousand island dressing served on a pumpernickel.
$8.99
#4 The Inspector
Boar’s head Spicy Buffalo Chicken Breast & Provolone with lettuce, tomato and Ranch dressing served on a sun dried tomato bagel.
$8.49
#5 The Commander
Thinly sliced Boar’s head roast beef, with lettuce, tomato, mayo and horseradish dressing served on a cheddar bagel.
$8.99
#6 The Captain BLT (NEW ITEM number)
A Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato Sandwich topped with Mayo and served on a multi-grain bagel.
$7.99
#7 The Lieutenant (Club)
A Sesame bagel with Tavern Ham, Smoked Turkey & Crispy Bacon strips, topped with lettuce, tomato, red onion and honey mustard dressing.
$8.49
#8 The Sergeant
Smoked turkey & Provolone Cheese with lettuce, tomato, red onion and mayo served on an onion bagel.
$8.49
#9 The Detective
Tavern Ham & Swiss Cheese with lettuce, tomato, red onion, Deli dressing served on a Sesame bagel.
$8.49
#9 ¾ The Gangsta
Tavern Ham, Salami, Pepperoni & Provolone Cheese with lettuce, tomato, red onion, and Deli—dressing served on an Everything bagel.
$8.99
#10 The Patrolman
Gourmet Chicken Salad with lettuce, tomato, and red onion served on a multi-grain bagel.
$8.49
#11 The Veggie Cadet (NEW item number)
V.L.T. veggie cream cheese, lettuce, & tomato served on a multi-grain bagel.
$6.99
#12 The Vegan Cadet (New item)
An L.T.O. spicy mustard with lettuce, tomato, red onion and cucumber.
$6.49
#13 Security Officer
Egg Salad on a Multi-Grain bagel with lettuce, tomato, and red onion.
$6.99

Explore

Our Menu

Bakery Items

Dozen Bagels

Bagel only

Bagel

Muffins (Blueberry, Cappuccino Chocolate Chunk, Strawberry Rhubarb or Blueberry Lemon) or a Cinnamon Bun

Scones (Apple Cinnamon, Blueberry or Raspberry White Chocolate)

Breakfast

Egg Sandwich

Gourmet Coffee

Order lunch #1-#13 or design your own Custom Bagel Sandwich

(Design your own: DYO) $8.49

Lunch Bagel Sandwiches

#1 NY’s Finest

#2 NYPD Blue

#3 The Chief

#4 The Inspector

#5 The Commander

#6 The Captain BLT (NEW ITEM number)

#7 The Lieutenant (Club)

#8 The Sergeant

#9 The Detective

#9 ¾ The Gangsta

#10 The Patrolman

#11 The Veggie Cadet (NEW item number)

#12 The Vegan Cadet (New item)

#13 Security Officer

Garden Salads

Large Salad : Spring Mix with

Small Garden Salad

Beverages

Fountain Drinks & Brewed Teas

Bottles

Assorted Milks

Regular or Flavored Coffee

All Prices listed are cash prices. Any items purchased using our card system will incur the 3% processing fee the company charges us.